Guide
Do Negative Ad Comments Hurt ROAS? What a 2026 Harvard Study Found
A 2026 Harvard Business School study found hiding harmful ad comments raised conversions and ROAS. What it tested, which comments to hide, and the limits.
Yes. A 2026 Harvard Business School working paper found that hiding harmful comments under ads improved real ad results. That included conversions and return on ad spend. Most brands still leave those comments up.
What did the Harvard study test?
Jiwoon Park and Julian De Freitas ran six studies. Two were large field experiments on live ad campaigns. The rest were online experiments that isolated what drives the effect. They asked whether managing the comments under an ad changes how the ad performs.
How much did ad performance change?
| Study | Setup | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Field study 1 | A financial services brand, 10 months, comment moderation and replies switched on | Registrations per ad click rose from 1.67% to 1.94%; total registrations rose 43.6% |
| Field study 2 | A/B test on Facebook and Instagram | Return on ad spend was about 48% higher (0.678 vs 0.459); cost per purchase fell from $667 to $454 |
| Online study 3 | Hiding and replying tested separately | Hiding harmful comments drove most of the gain |
In the first study, negative sentiment among visible comments also fell from 57% to 43%.
Is it the replies or the hiding that matters?
Mostly the hiding. The researchers also tested the two separately, and hiding harmful comments explained most of the gain. Replies still matter for questions and real complaints, but the first win is removing the comments that make an ad look unmanaged.
Why do negative comments hurt ad performance?
They lower trust in the brand. The authors compare harmful comments to broken windows: they signal that nobody is watching. People trusted the brand less when harmful comments stayed up, and that showed up in clicks and purchase intent. This held even when the comments had nothing to do with the brand.
Does Meta’s algorithm penalize ads with negative comments?
The study did not test that. It measured how people react to the comments they see, not how Meta ranks the ad. What it does show is that buyers read the thread, and a thread full of spam and attacks costs you conversions.
Which comments should you hide?
Hide comments that harm everyone or attack the brand without substance. That means spam, scams, hate, profanity and personal information. Keep real complaints visible and answer them, since they help buyers judge you.
Should you hide or delete negative comments?
Hide them in most cases. On Facebook and Instagram, a hidden comment stays visible to the person who posted it, so they rarely notice. Delete only scams and abuse. Our guide on how to hide negative comments on Facebook and Instagram ads walks through the settings.
When can hiding backfire?
When a platform openly shows that a brand hid comments attacking it. In that case, hiding brand attacks lowered purchase intent. Hiding comments that are harmful to everyone did not backfire. A brand saying it moderates its own comments did not hurt results either.
What should paid social teams do with this?
Treat the comment section as part of ad performance as well as reputation.
Get paid media and community management working together. In most companies they sit in different teams.
Moderate around the clock. The study notes that only about 5% of brands use a dedicated comment tool.
How does Pinpoint handle ad comments?
Pinpoint’s AI agents hide spam, scams and off-brand comments on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok and X ads as they land. They answer product questions and real complaints in your brand’s voice, and send anything sensitive to your team. Every agent runs in shadow mode for about a week first, so your team approves each reply before it goes live. We compared seven tools, Pinpoint among them, in our guide to the best comment moderation tools.
What are the limits of the study?
It is a working paper, so it has not been peer reviewed yet. The second field study was small, with 22 purchases against 15. Both field studies used one vendor’s tool, BrandBastion.
Read the full paper: Automated Comment Moderation Enhances Social Media Advertising Performance (Harvard Business School Working Paper 27-011). Adrian’s summary on LinkedIn covers the same findings.
FAQ
Do negative comments hurt ad performance?
Yes. In a 2026 Harvard Business School study, ads with moderated comments got about 48% higher return on ad spend in an A/B test on Facebook and Instagram.
Should you reply to negative comments on ads?
Reply to real complaints and questions. Hide spam, scams and abuse. The study found hiding harmful comments mattered more than replying to them.
How many brands moderate their ad comments?
Few. The Harvard study notes that only about 5% of brands use a dedicated comment management tool.
Can you moderate TikTok ad comments?
Yes. Tools like Pinpoint cover TikTok ad comments alongside Instagram, Facebook and X. The Harvard field studies ran on Facebook and Instagram.
TRUSTED BY 500+ BRANDS shaping culture
Your brand. Our agents.
Like bringing on a team. Not another tool.
See what Pinpoint’s agents would do with your comments, DMs and ad activity, live on a 30-minute call.
More guides
Sprinklr Alternatives (2026): What to Use Instead
Looking for a Sprinklr alternative? Compare Sprout Social, Emplifi, Dash Social, Hootsuite and Pinpoint by use case, with dated pricing and how to switch.
Best Comment Moderation Tools for Ads and Instagram (2026)
Compare 7 comment moderation tools for Instagram, Facebook and TikTok ads and posts: what each one hides, whether it replies, and dated pricing.
Nectar Social Alternatives (2026): What to Use Instead
Looking for a Nectar Social alternative? Compare Sprout Social, Emplifi, BrandBastion and Pinpoint by use case, with dated pricing and how to switch.















